Skip to content
English
More support View Your Support Tickets
Contact us
  • There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

How do I get more conversions from my existing website traffic?

Getting more conversions doesn't always mean getting more visitors. Often, the fastest path to growth is turning a higher percentage of the traffic you already have into leads and customers.

This practice is called conversion rate optimization (CRO), and it focuses on removing friction, building trust, and making it easier for visitors to take the next step on your website.

Most small business websites convert between 1% and 3% of their traffic. That means for every 1,000 visitors, 970 or more leave without taking action. Even small improvements to your conversion rate can have an outsized impact on revenue without spending another dollar on advertising.

Start with What's Costing You the Most

Before testing new ideas, look for the places where visitors are dropping off. Your analytics can tell you which pages have high traffic but low engagement, where users abandon forms, and which traffic sources produce the least results.

Common problem areas include:

  • Homepage headlines that don't clearly communicate what you do or who you serve within a few seconds.
  • Forms with too many fields. Reducing your form to 3-5 essential fields can noticeably improve completion rates.
  • Slow page load times. If your site takes longer than 3 seconds to load, a significant portion of visitors will leave before they see anything.
  • Weak or generic calls-to-action. Buttons that say "Submit" or "Learn More" don't give visitors a compelling reason to click. Specific, benefit-oriented language performs better.
  • No social proof near decision points. Testimonials, client logos, and results placed close to your calls-to-action help visitors feel confident about reaching out.

Quick Wins You Can Implement This Week

Some CRO improvements take planning, but a few changes can make an immediate difference:

  1. Add your phone number above the fold. For service businesses especially, visible contact information signals legitimacy and gives ready-to-buy visitors a direct path to you.
  2. Make your primary CTA easy to find on mobile. If visitors have to scroll or hunt for the button, you're losing conversions. Place your main action within thumb reach on mobile devices.
  3. Fix your 404 error page. Instead of a dead end, use your 404 page to guide lost visitors back to useful content or your contact page.
  4. Replace stock photography with real images. Photos of your actual team, office, or work build trust in ways that generic stock images cannot.

Think Beyond the Click

Conversion optimization isn't just about the moment someone fills out a form. The experience before and after that moment matters just as much.

Before the conversion: Make sure each page answers the visitor's core question, "Is this for me?" Clear headlines, relevant proof, and a logical page structure help visitors self-qualify quickly.

After the conversion: Your thank-you page and follow-up emails are part of the conversion experience. A confirmation page that simply says "Thank you" is a missed opportunity. Use it to set expectations, offer a related resource, or guide the new lead to a next step.

When to Consider a Structured CRO Program

Quick fixes will get you early results, but sustained improvement comes from a systematic approach: auditing your full conversion funnel, prioritizing changes by potential impact, testing variations, and building on what works.

If you're generating steady traffic but not seeing the leads or sales to match, a structured conversion optimization program can uncover the specific barriers holding your site back.

For a deeper look at 27 specific CRO fixes ranked by ROI, including quick wins, monthly projects, and quarterly strategic changes, read our complete guide: CRO Guide: 27 Website Fixes Ranked by ROI.

Key Takeaways

  • You don't need more traffic to get more leads. Improving your conversion rate is often faster and more cost-effective.
  • Start with the biggest friction points: slow load times, unclear headlines, long forms, and weak CTAs.
  • Place social proof and contact information where visitors make decisions.
  • Optimize the full experience, including what happens after someone converts.
  • For lasting results, move from one-off fixes to a repeatable testing and optimization process.

If you're not sure where to start or want help identifying what's holding your site back, schedule a consultation and we'll walk through your site together.